Originally Posted by
Disktrasa
Yeah to clarify Protection Warriors can stil tank Lich King 25 Heroic if geared enough, they have good cool downs to handle more soul reapers then paladins for example.
I've been in many runs with Protection warrior both MT and OT on that particular fight and the good once that time their abilities properly don't go down and don't have to rely on something like ardent defender.
The thing is still, they take more damage then they did on retail, call it bug or not whatever, I have 1 and I think it's the most fun and challenging Tank specc out there, its great fun every time.
If you want to go a protection warrior, it's really a good choice all the way up.
They work on all dungeons and they are only blamed on upon being "bad" because Lich King does such insane melee damage.