All of you that are asking for a wipe on Neltharion are pretty clueless. IF they wipe the server you're going to be facing the same issues that caused people to leave the realm in the first place. If they do NOT fix the content and wipe everything you will have a fresh clean server, WITH THE SAME ISSUES, with the same bugged content. A wipe is not the solution, give Neltharion back its regular updates, fix the stuff that's broken and people will come back.
- Fix the outstanding class issues (Cough Warlocks, Prot Warriors etc)
- Give us Nefarian in BWD and (BWD HC Which has not been seen since 4.0.6)
- Fix Throne of the Four Winds(It was doable at a time) Slipstreams, Council and Al'akir N/HC
- Fix the Cataclysm zones (This is a large part of the expansion) Vashjir had started to be fixed, what happened?
- Find a way to port content from your WOTLK realms to the Cataclysm Core. (This will make up the majority of older content)
- Fix Dragon Soul and Firelands (Ragnaros HC World in Flames and Spine of Deathwing just not doable after Warmaster), Drakes to Yor and Zonozz
- Script the Legendary questlines for Rogues and the Staff (You have Valanyr and Shadowmourne on WOTLK)
- Fix the issue with Void Storage items disappearing from time to time
- Fix the Cataclysm Dungeons that have broken, ZA/ZG HoT/ET (And re-enforce the Hour of Twilight dungeon completion for Dragon Soul)
- THE MOLTEN FRONT. This has NEVER been seen. This is a meme.
- The Battle for Tol Barad.... promised but never actually implemented. (also a meme.)
and lastly
Give regular content updates and show that you care about the server, people will come back. Quit spending time on the ridiculous Cow Darts and Hide and Seek. Most people would prefer content updates over trivial events.
A wipe is not the solution. You want to create level 1 characters and get to 85 on a fresh realm, while most of the content is pretty bugged and needs to be worked around? What are you going to do when you're all 85 in 339 crafted gear? Sit around a /campfire and sing Kum Ba Yah? What happens when you want to do a dungeon or raid? You will need to progress through content and if that content isn't working then good luck doing that. If you're coming from WOTLK or a server that's pretty much complete and experience Cataclysm currently, you will become frustrated and leave. Then we're right back where we started.