@Eva
Yeah I see the mistake I made, too quickly assumed 1% crit=1% more damage. I am here to learn and that's why I wrote "Or am I missing something?". I have no problem changing my view if a person can give a good explanation, hence my comment about this not being an intelligent conversation. You did provide me with some good sources and for that I thank you. What is further interesting is that people in the EJ thread are claiming that top DKs in the world chose to reallocate their point from UA to BcB or BI. So 1 talent point in either BI or BcB is better than Unbreakable Armor at some point? Hmm.
@DarkenedHue
Yeah I will run Subversion 3/3 anyway because of new progressing 3.3.5 server. Since BcB scales with gear it might take a while before I go that route.
I feel like I should have been more clear with this as well. Talent setup seems to differ a lot depending on what Raid(s) are currently available. I might argue even subspeccing into blood for 5/5 Bladed Armor and 5/5 Dark Conviction might be superior in the start, but what do I know. I'm just guessing again.
@Gnimo
I am not trying to invent a new wheel, just getting a better understanding of mechanics etc of 3.3.5. But your are not giving any sources or back up your statements or telling me what's wrong in my math. Frankly I don't care if I'm wrong or not, I just want have a better insight. You are basing everything on your experience, and while that is fine for some it's not for me. But thanks to "Eva" I have some good sources. Even though he/she is kinda salty :p