and you won't get bored from ICC and RS that you've been raiding for over 5 years on every single server out there????? also, i'm talking about arenas and pvp, since arena points are acquired WEEKLY and to get a full gear, you need a lot of weeks, even at a high rating. my point was: as soon as we collect the season gear, the realm will progress and as soon as we collect the other season gear, the realm will again progress, ruining our efforts completely. on wrathful gear, this will turn into another ragnaros/deathwing funserver after only a few months, making this unique realm not very unique.
one more thing: they can increase the difficulty on naxx if it's too easy, this IS a hardcore realm, right? not 100% raids should be successful if it is (or anywhere close to that %).