I think you've missed the whole point;

The weapon doesn't carry your ***, classes do. It's point and blank OBVIOUS that Shadowmourne will do more damage than a PvP weapon and for optimized damage output you're going to rock Shadowmourne or Oathbinder as an Arms Warrior. You're sitting here trying to compare the most obvious fact; Shadowmourne > Wrathful Weapon. Everyone in this god damn game knows that and there's a really simple reason why Shadowmourne is lighted up with an orange color; Now the difference is that most of the people rocking Shadowmourne's don't know what to do with it so stating that a Shadowmourne will destroy you under whatever the condition is (or through your so called experience) is A FALSE AND PRETENTIOUS STATEMENT. Not wanting to recognize this single point declares that your experience didn't provide you much on the long run.



Then don't state that the weapon will destroy you when it's a class situation and not a weapon situation. There's a huge difference between a weapon carry and a skillful player. And yes: A disc Priest can survive a Shadowmourne if properly played and this is a fact - Specially in Arenas if he has a partner with the right mind set to peel the damage out of him.
Pretty much this. 6.3k retiden can run up and chunk you down nearly as fast with glorenz then a 6.7k smourniden. Barely any difference that i can see with all other gear being equal. 200~ str and a proc that may or may not proc enough, meh not sure wut the QQ is about. Not saying SM isnt powerful, just you guys seem to hype it up a lot when heroics are nearly on par.