So lately on Icecrown, I've been getting into dungeons to find tanks that are just being really stupid.
Here's an example. A druid tank that was specc'd for feral tanking...but refused to use bear form. Instead, he was attempting to tank all of Slave Pens in cat form, as a level 59. Add on the fact that when I asked him nicely to swap over to bear form, his only response was "stfu :)". Once we wiped again, I told him he needed to either swap or I'd leave, and he told me, "**** off." and then abandoned.
Another one: Get thrown into Hell(fire Ramparts) with a level 58 Paladin. But guess what! That's right, you got it - he's Ret. Oh, and he had no idea what Righteous Fury is when I asked, and after we wiped on the first pull, he asked the Warrior dps to tank. So I asked him why he came in as a tank if he didn't want to, and he said, "so no wait get in". I promptly left.
I could go on...for days. But really, you just can't make this stuff up. I honestly get an average of one decent tank out of every 4 dungeons I attempt. So all I'm asking is, WHAT IS GOING ON with all the tanks being so...mentally defective lately?