I used Rawr to compare them and surprisingly (for me), the LK fist is rated much better. I'm unsure if this is a problem with Rawr messing up the proc or if it's just that clear.
Also, anyone having an idea for how much the proc accounts for at its current state on Icecrown?
and a benmog is a mog that looks like ****, not everything you do hheheheh
in any case, the reason why pugius is better is because of stats, and because of the fact that enhs scale very poorly with the black bruise proc (melee exclusively) as enh does a lot of spell damage, which scales with basically everything but the black bruise proc
RAWR doesn't calculate Black Bruise or Tiny Abomination properly, however Enhsim does, which sims Black Bruise heroic higher dps than Pugius heroic. White and Windfury hits are both physical and account for around 60% of your damage so Black Bruise heroic is still viable.
well ye ofc bb hc is still viable also the proc (necro touch) scales well with haste. But stats go a long way and not having secondary stats sets the weapon back
The only main hand better than Black Bruise Heroic is Havoc's Call Heroic; however, the OP's question was about the best MH fist weapon. The answer is Black Bruise Heroic.