But shaman's don't even want Spirit, it's a useless stat for them? I feel like it would legitimately be ninja looting on a trinket if it was a spirit trinket, however what about a spellpower + crit trinket means it is a dps caster trinket and not a mutual tribket between dps and healer? That makes no sense to me.
I guess what troubles me about that ruling is that this isn't a situation of say a warrior needing on a trinket just for the sake of selling it for some quick cash, it's a trinket that has no dps exclusive stats on it (like hit rating), so what about it would make it dps only? Let alone the fact the guy threatened me, then when I told him no he offered to pay me, i still said no, and then went back to threatening me.