WotLK Starting ret PVP, what weapon should I use?

[ofnir993]

Hello everybody, after a long time PvEming I would like to start doing some pvp, but I'm not sure what weapon should I use.

At the moment I have in my bags/bank:

Bloodfall HC
Bryntroll HC
Cryptmaker HC
Ramaladni's Blade of Culling HC


I started using Bryntroll but I dunno if it's the best choice for a ret pally. With my current pvp set I also have a grand total of 0 expertise so maybe Ramaladni may be a good choice?

[ItWasCraft]

Bloodfall provides by far the best stats from the weapons that you have. Cryptmaker and ramaladni have a ton of ARP, which you don't need as ret in pvp. Expertise is also not so useful. Bryntroll also has a nice proc, but since you cant increase its damage, like an unholy dk would, Bloodfall is your best option. That is my advice, tried to put some logic behind it :)

[Evangelion]

I'd say go with Bryn HC.

[jetiwzmul]

depend of rest your gear :

What is the general weapon ranking? This compares all weapons and uses the lists above (so hit/expertise is wasted)
Shadowmourne - > Oathbinder, Charge of the Ranger-General - > Glorenzelg, High-Blade of the Silver Hand - > Bloodfall - > Bryntroll, the Bone Arbiter - > Warmace of Menethil - > Cryptmaker

HC weapons .source : /http://elitistjerks.com/