Did Expansion Convertion a few hours ago, my hunter which i transfered first went down smoothly... But my paladin is still awol from all lists etc. Just says : CHARACTER TRANSFERS
Can's transfer from Outland to Frostmourne has completed.
Aintmyday's transfer from Outland to Frostmourne is pending import.
Well all that nervous clicking you probably did kinda slowed the system, I can confirm some transfers can take up to 7 (WORKING) days, as was the case with my transfer.
Do not be worry about it, give it some time and if like after a week its still the same, THEN, contact warmane support.