Banning ninjas

Did Utgarde Pinnacle today, was the only enchanter in the group. I don't need on any items, I let everyone roll disenchant over me, not caring too much. We get to the last boss and the epic drops. I check if anyone actually needed on it, and after seeing that no one actually did, I roll need to atleast get that disenchant. Now is this REALLY a 6-day ban worthy offense? I was not intentionally trying to screw fellow players over or anything of the sort. None of the other members had enchanting, and they get mad at me for taking the materials I actually need, when they are simply profiting FROM ACTUAL ENCHANTING without doing leveling a single skill point in the profession. I would understand getting banned for taking items out of spite towards other players, but I simply feel like it is completely unfair to be profiting from someone who spent 2000 gold leveling a profession and actually needs the materials, unlike the other 4 freeloaders.

You only select need if you need the item. If you want to disenchant or sell it then select disenchant or greed. Even if none of them had enchanting on those chars they might have it on other chars. And you are still doing the dungeon together and distributing the items together even if it's for disenchanting.

I think he talked about the loot from last boss which is BOP and he let others roll de for all the BOE. But I have no idea that can lead to ban. there's some enchanter (not lodaeron) still pretty much need every thing and nobody cares.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by asken95

Did Utgarde Pinnacle today, was the only enchanter in the group. I don't need on any items, I let everyone roll disenchant over me, not caring too much. We get to the last boss and the epic drops. I check if anyone actually needed on it, and after seeing that no one actually did, I roll need to atleast get that disenchant. Now is this REALLY a 6-day ban worthy offense? I was not intentionally trying to screw fellow players over or anything of the sort. None of the other members had enchanting, and they get mad at me for taking the materials I actually need, when they are simply profiting FROM ACTUAL ENCHANTING without doing leveling a single skill point in the profession. I would understand getting banned for taking items out of spite towards other players, but I simply feel like it is completely unfair to be profiting from someone who spent 2000 gold leveling a profession and actually needs the materials, unlike the other 4 freeloaders.

---

I think you're wrong, like posted before: you only roll on stuff you actually need. If you want to disenchant, select that - or greed. It was your decision to not roll on stuff before.
Also your "I need it as an enchanter" argument is wrong. Everyone who wants his stuff enchanted needs the materials, professional enchanter or not. In 99,9% of cases enchanters enchant other peoples' stuff for mats + tip, so how would you have more right to roll on enchanting mats then anyone else? Doesn't sound to me like you would need the stuff to actually skill up, and even then I'd think you're wrong.

But i don't understand why you'd get a 6-day ban for something like that. It's not like you're a real ninja, sounds to me like that could have been discussed with the others. Or did you just leave and put everyone else on ignore without speaking to them? Personally, i wouldn't care much about it if noone actually needed the item.