So, I count myself fairly lucky,
Last night I was thinking "I wish there was a WOTLK private server or something, surely there is" Did some looking found this place.
Awesome.
Wish I could Play with some progression, kinda relive this the patches.
Awesome, had no idea a new server was just resetting for a season.
It's PVE, Awesome, I refuse to play when PvP isn't optional. Ganks aren't fun, people are aholes, and I don't want to deal with that kind of play unless I am in a battleground. Love Wintergrasp, Love Battlegrounds and Arena, Hate struggling with a few adds and some Opposite faction comes in and kills me, or wants to start something when really what I want to do is play the bag space mini game while in a safe spot in stranglethorn vale.
Overworld PvP was nice at this time of the game....mostly, but that is not the nostalgia I was after. When I saw this server and the activity, I thought this is great, seems like the previous consesus was PvP was the desired type. at least the desired type by really loud vocal people.
I am a new player to the community, my wife is now wanting to join, I am sure there will be other people like me who don't want to use the forums, (I don't want to, I want to level my priest) If there is one thing I have noticed its this, the people who don't want PvP are the same people who don't feel like argueing about it on a forum, not cause any other reason then they normally have better things to do, the game isn't so important I would normally want to spend time talking about why my preferred playstyle is valid, but since this is a new decision, I just wanted to say if it was a PvP only server available I would not have joined here.
I am sure some of the devs and people who work on this server do review these forums, if you see this, please note for every one of these post you see, you probably have another 100 players happy with this decision. Every PvP player who is unhappy is free to make a character on one of the other servers I am sure.
I would feel more comfortable to know after the year is up I don't have to get dumped into a PvP Server though, If I don't see some announcement on that, (it may already exist, I haven't looked all over the site I have been playing the game) I will probably continue to look for a different server, I am just too happy with having old school wow right now.

