Originally Posted by
SelfishTiger
At high gear levels (390+), I feel Arms and Fury are fairly equal. Although Fury needs more attention to use.
Arms dps is linear to ilvl, you can hit the enemy every GCD even if you are in greens.
At sub 378 levels, Fury isn't good because you don't have enough Crit to keep Flurry (30% haste) up all the time.
Lack of Flurry buff means lower chance to enrage, also lesser rage generation. Without flurry you are guaranteed to run into phases when you aren't enraged, where even Raging blow becomes unavailable.
That Said, there are some advantages to fury, like higher chance for battle trance to proc, and the ability to use Recklessness 2 times in most encounters, while arms can usually manage to fit in 1 recklessness.
Bone link Fetish is great for all plate dps, but it is GODLY for fury warriors. The proc hits harder than execute.
I will probably do more dps as Fury on a single target dummy for 10 million damage.
Verdict:
BUT i think arms is better because it requires much lesser attention, and you can focus on Boss mechanics and staying alive. Fury you are glancing at your action bar too often, too much to manage.
I have observed, for dangerous bosses like Ascendant Council HC, my arms warr raiders maybe lose 2k dps, while my decorated fury raider's dps is cut in half :DD