Once guilds where done with dragon soul, people just stopped, unless they did pvp or sold pve runs. Goto the battel.net/reddit forums under wow and look it up, im srsly not going to hold your hand on settled consensus on 3 yr old pve content, the pve community was highly disappointed, fed up with the end game and gave up on perpetuating it.
Its right there, just because i liked aspects of cata, including some of its instances doesn't mean as i whole i believe it was a success.
But keep cherry-picking what i say and wrap it with false equivalences.

