And the truth shall set you free
I've been seeing alot of posts about how warmane is p2w lately.
It's pretty obvious that donating does not "make you win". You can't donate and recieve a free win. You can donate for items, but you must earn your "wins" on your own (unless your paying someone to play your character for you which is illegal).
That being said the statement "p2w" does raise a few valid points of interest.
It's a little bothersome that someone who has never cleared heroic ICC is running around in heroic ICC gear. It's not very fair that someone is running around with arena gear when they've never achieved rating for it. It makes you wonder how someone who never cleared heroic RS is running around with heroic scale trinkets. It's disheartening to see people using legendary weapons when they've never completed a quest for it.
Part of what makes skilled players skilled is they're ability to earn the items they have. However, donations offer a player a chance to receive things they could possibly never earn in-game on they're own.
No it's not pay to win, but it sure does change the game and gameplay entirely.