How my last ICC went...

[penzin]

Hello everyone,

posting this on this Forum too because no one seems to care about the other ones.

So I was hosting a Icc lately and I was BiS Pve. The trinket I wanted that was better for me in PvP finally dropped. Then we got to rolling. I asked if it was okay that I roll on the Item to everyone that is eligible to roll on it.

One person told me if the other person is fine with it, I could. The other person was fine with it. Suddenly he said: No, I am fine if he rolls in your stead and if he wins and goves it to you I‘m okay with it. I was like great. I convinced the undergeared hunter(5k gs) to give me the trinket. He approved because he was happy to even get into ICC. So we rolled the items. The hunter won it. I was really excited. But then the rogue said: It‘s bannable giving items to other People in raid that didn‘t roll for it. And I was like: seriously? So I gave the trinket to the hunter after all.

Before he was like: „Man people are really *******s on warmane reporting because of the most little ****.“

And after he lost the trinket he wanted: „I’m gonna report you for taking a item in raid that isn‘t better than your current PvE item. It is obvious that PvP is an offspec roll... etc.“
It was like as if he studied Warmane law at university or something.

Hypocrites on this server are real.

Please make all the rules(detailled at that) visible to all players somehow.

I for example didn‘t even know that gifting an item to someone else in a raid was forbidden. Make Warmane more transparant please.

[Invictum]

Gifting won item to someone else is forbidden?

I can’t wait to hear the background of it. If I win the ****ing roll, I can destroy the ****ing item, why wouldn’t I be able to give it to someone, as long as I was ELIGIBLE for rolling?

Makes no sense. I’ll say that rogue was just a rogue and decided to **** you up, but we’ll see.

[Disktrasa]

Ninjas can be really crafty sometimes, like when they equip some crap item just to be able to roll for items for their friends.

[Obnoxious]

But then the rogue said: It‘s bannable giving items to other People in raid that didn‘t roll for it.

There's no such rule. The only thing covered is who is eligible to roll. What they do with whatever they win is up to them. They could even destroy it and laugh at the other people rolling for it if they wanted. You were just conned.