You didnt read my post carefully.
I didnt ask for every servers to get a x1 xp rate (i honestly thought 'are they serious?!' where i read about it)
My first question was if it would be FEASIBLE to be able to personally set your own xp rate, to level up at the pace you see fit.
Wanna get to max lvl pronto? set it at x 20. Wanna take your time? x1. Balanced approach? x5. Everyone happy!
Second of all, you said you were new to private servers right? Well before Warmane there was Molten. And in Molten, there was actually a relatively populated x1 server. I read its now relegated to being a test server, and since its not advertised like the other servers, the population is very well likely to be abysmal. I also asked if it was possible to shut off xp gains in 3.3.5 and know where the alliance npc would be. But no one has replied to this so i guess there is no way :(.
Lastly, you really do genuinely seem to 'not get' why ppl ask for this. Hard to explain since its 100% subjective. But to me, there is just no satisfaction, no catharsis in exploring areas you greatly outlevel, no danger, no adventure, no point. Example: Yesterday i was questin around Theramore and came across an iron deposit. YUMMY. Thing is though, there was 3 spiders 2 lvl above me around. Had to think, how do i get to it? Opted to charge, fear em (good chance to resist), mine it and GTFO. It worked! I (my character) escaped mortal danger and got my sweet booty. Satisfaction, catharsis, serotonin.
If i got there with a lvl 58 (explore azeroth before goin in TBC) well... no need for iron since my engineering and mining would likely be at 300, no decision making since ill stomp them spiders, no risk, no danger, no fun, no victory, no profit, no point :(. There is a reason why blizz made the leveling faster and easier, but there is also a reason why they gave ppl the option to turn off xp gains in Cata.
These high xp rates, they remind me of new game plus in Chrono Trigger. They are GREAT when you want to see all the endings, all what the end game has to offer. But they generallly leave the whole grand adventure lacking as you one shot everything in your path (even bosses) and every goodies you find? obsolete just like all the gadgets im making with engineering. It cheapens everything.
That being said im also a fan of high xp rates. Would i level another dam rogue from 1 to 80 at x1 for the hundred time? No way!!! I would opt for friggin x20 xp if i could and get to end game asap. I would just like to have the option for slower leveling like we used to, cuz i surprised myself by wanting the leveling on my warrior to last (would have rerolled on Lordaeron if could). I dont want every server to have x1, and i get ppl wanting to get to end game asap (i like to have this option too), but i find myself wanting the grand adventure once again on this character. If i want to endgame, i have plenty of chars to choose from.