I think this thread highlights a bigger issue with how Warmane handles its community and the expectations around moderation. Sure, some people might say “just use /ignore” or dismiss toxic behavior as “the way the internet is,” but that approach doesn’t address the actual problem: enabling a culture where harassment is acceptable because there’s no accountability.
I understand that GMs can’t moderate every minor insult, but when players take the time to report behavior they feel crosses a line, it’s because they care about the community. Ignoring reports, dismissing them as overreactions, or mocking players for raising concerns doesn’t solve anything—it just makes people feel like their concerns don’t matter.
Take Helbra’s example of someone threatening to track and kill another player. Even if those threats aren’t credible, dismissing them with “just ignore it” is irresponsible. At the very least, there should be consistency in how these reports are handled. If Warmane doesn’t intend to act on certain behaviors, they need to make that clear in their policies so players aren’t left guessing what qualifies as actionable harassment.
As for the argument that “this is how the internet works,” I think that’s outdated. Plenty of modern communities have shown that clear rules and active, fair moderation can create healthier environments. Players aren’t asking for GMs to babysit every argument—they just want basic standards of respect to be enforced.
Ultimately, Warmane’s approach to these issues will determine the kind of community they foster. If they want to grow and maintain their player base, they need to take these concerns seriously, even if it’s just issuing warnings for smaller offenses. Otherwise, the message they’re sending is that toxic behavior is acceptable here, and that’s not the kind of environment many of us want to be part of.