TG Fury vs SMF: Currently SMF is broken to the point where the talent does not grant any damage increase. Numbers are hard to compare but easy to conclude. TG Fury>SMF
Fury vs Arms: : This is what I have seen on raids with an arms warrior. Shoutout to Rallik, he's a beast.
Arms-Pro's: Controlled Burst (Deadly Calm). High Constant Damage at 3 stacks of Slaughter. High mobility. High AoE damage. Better rage income. +4% Physical Damage Raid Wide. Good at switching. Easier Rotation. Colossus Smash upkeep
Arms-Con's: Drastic DPS loss on rotation mistakes. Stance Dance to use Recklessness (latency can become a problem). RNG .
- Fury has a higher burst than arms, without questioning. After your burst is over as fury, this is where arms picks up. Arms can sustain high damage for a longer duration therefore, on longer fights arms can be stronger. Arms is also fairly better at switching targets since Charge grants rage and +crit on mortal strike and slam compared to a fury warrior's intercept which instead grants no rage and costs rage to use. On AoE, Sweeping Strikes + Bladestorm will make you jelly. The only RNG factor as Arms is Wrecking Crew (Enrage) and Strikes of Oportunity (Mastery). On fury, RNG affects Enrage and instant slams (aka your rotation)
Now, on the next couple of SS you will see the overall dps and damage on certain boss fights on BWD and one in Cho'gall. Rallik is the arms warrior on recount. I am a bit more geared than he is as well. about 2-3 more ilvl. Make your own judgement. Either Arms or Fury is fine, choose your playstyle.
Magmaw 25N
Maloriak 25N (He died early-Raid was over after this? Hence Why I'm in orgrimmar)
Cho'gall 25N