Ninja Scenario - Please Advise
Background: I just had an encounter with an unfortunate pug Icc 10 group on horde on Icecrown WOTLK where an item was taken from me. Here's the scenario (as I wait with GM ticket open)
Scenario: I'm a warrior tank, rolling MS dps as I stated from the start and lead announced confirming my spec change. On Marrow, I rolled Offspec for tanking choker and won. On Gunship 10hc, I tanked the mobs on our ship. After the fight, Saronite Gargoyle Cloak Hc dropped and I won with a Main spec role of 90.
The case: The leader, a frost dk, claimed that the cloak with crit+haste stats is not for warrior. He was wearing Shadowvault slayer cloak (agil crit haste 25n gs) and I Relentless Gladiator's Cloak. Now, I realize that for a warrior the EoF cloak is better. However, as I have a pvp cloak as the alternative, I very much needed this pve cloak. In addition, the EoF agil arp cloak is better for both classes.
After arguing that starting off claiming I rolled main spec for the marrow neck, to accepting I came as dps but it's not for warrior, the leader took the cloak and started the next fight. My ask is, logically, what should have happened here?