Then again, everything anyone has posted in this thread has been opinion, from the very beginning where your beloved (may I mention, PvE guild) leader declared that Alliance have no "PvP guilds". I took an issue with this opinion, by stating a fact, in that arenas are the most balanced PvP environment, and are where a vast majority of the "PvP" players compete. As such, a "PvP guild" must also have players competing in that environment. I totally accept that this is my opinion, but it flows from facts (namely that Blizzard devs themselves admit to 3v3 arenas being the most balanced environment) and common sense.
To provide an opinion-ception, my second opinion is that my first opinion is more well founded on facts than the OPs.
But hey, you're right. I'm not qualified to talk about PvP, as it turns out I'm a PvE player, since I do quests, talk with friends, fish, and cook every now and then. How could I ever talk about PvP, having led so called "PvP guilds" or having been r3 in 3v3. Neither does the fact that I have 1300+ rated BG rating on my mage and 700+ rating on my hunter mean anything. The real PvP after all, is in who can farm the most greenies in a random BG, or who can form the best 40 man raid to kill a bunch of NPCs in a city. How foolish of me to compete with such amazing PvPers...