Wouldn't be the first time I see a holy pala with festergut plaguebringer pants.
-
Rock n' Roll Racing Champion
-
The Lightbringer
Hunters have dual wield, the sword in question has good stats for hunter. Why couldn't you let Hunter roll for it? It's the same with casters having two options; staves, or main hand and off-hand.
Agility polearms are fine for Paladins. If you want to see Oathbinder on (arms) Warrior, you could try your luck at arenas. Furys can't equip polearms with other weapons, so yeah, that's a no go.
Your logic of loot is at min-max/BiS level, yet the raid loot rules for the raid were more or less basic MS>OS (I assume it was standard BoE+primo res, maybe with an additional item res). With this setup, Hunter was entirely allowed to roll MS for the sword.
Holy Paladins don't care about armor type, they care about stats. If the stats are better on leather item than on the alternative plate item, they'll want that leather item. It's not rocket science.
-
Member
I would like a Staff to tell me that, not you bro, as it is not enough to take a screen and take that as evidence. Since it would clearly cause a mismatch in the dice rules in general. If I was referring to warrior with polearms, I was talking about this being warrior arms. So, any gm or staff in the post that can confirm this for me, I just need a screen.
-
Member
@Obnoxious If you could help me to confirm the last answer of our friend @OhieMitzen, from his last answer it would be great, as I say I need just a screen, if it would not be too much trouble, to have your support :)
-
Rock n' Roll Racing Champion
A game master banned you. That's your confirmation right there.
-
Overwatcher
I give Forum support, not in-game support. If, as Shred says, getting banned for this isn't enough to tell you, go open a ticket and ask a GM for their ruling in your made up scenario, after your ban is over. My only purpose here was telling you what got you banned and why, since you seemed to not take it from players: you were banned for not giving an item to the highest eligible roller, making up some personal ruling of what belongs to whom on the spot, breaking your own raid rules (or absence of them).
-
Member
Invented? are you reading what you are answering me in the first place, and the other players too? I have never said that with this, I want to get my ban removed, I want to have clear rules for class allocation, which you seem to evade or I don't know what you are answering me. But thanks, I proceed to send a clear ticket after 30days ironic D:
-
Member
If you learn to read, the only thing the gm says is that a hunter can use a weapon and because it gives him agility he batches for that, I just want to know if I can do the same with a warrior, with a shovel or practically with all classes, as I run out of mana being a DPS Retry, I could batch from plate items that gives me intellect for example, because the paladin uses mana :)
-
Rock n' Roll Racing Champion
You can give intellect gear to a retri and see what happens.
How do you think being deliberately obtuse is going to help you?
-
Overwatcher
We'll probably see him again next ban.
