WotLK Warrior or Death Knight tank?

[lvenonl]

I've always played as a Warrior tank but I'm thinking about rolling a Death Knight this time. What do you guys suggest?

EDIT: Forgot to ask, are the Death Knight quests properly scripted on Lordaeron?

[Handepsilon]

Not sure if they've scripted Light of Dawn yet. Also don't forget to get that mailbox 'quest' in the field of Havenshire.

As for DK tanking, it feels immensely harder. For me, I can't seem to hold aggro with D&D and diseases alone (blood boil too btw). I've also met DK tanks who can't hold aggro as well as all the pala/warrior tanks I've met. That's just me though.

Besides Prot Warrior has quite a lot of useful traits. And by default they have that almost-anti front melee ability called shield block for those nasty times. If I have to choose between the two, I's say Warrior

[lvenonl]

I'm not sure. Sometimes I feel like playing another class for a change but at the same time I don't wanna leave my warrior :(

[Handepsilon]

I think that goes for everyone, for various reason. The levelling hassle, the different playstyle, or just because the toon feels so charaterized for you. It's normal

[andresio]

Not sure if they've scripted Light of Dawn yet. Also don't forget to get that mailbox 'quest' in the field of Havenshire.

As for DK tanking, it feels immensely harder. For me, I can't seem to hold aggro with D&D and diseases alone (blood boil too btw). I've also met DK tanks who can't hold aggro as well as all the pala/warrior tanks I've met. That's just me though.

Besides Prot Warrior has quite a lot of useful traits. And by default they have that almost-anti front melee ability called shield block for those nasty times. If I have to choose between the two, I's say Warrior

Same here, im having the worse time of my wow-life tanking with dks, more tan 5mobs === imposirburu!, im sticking for the challenge but im starting to realize that DKs are ment to be MT 1 target is super-easy to hold, **** HC's if ur with geared dpsers, i just face that im not matching their threat and it becomes a healer problem hehe