WOWLK warrior tank or paladin tank ?

[tareq]

hi all im thinking in rolling a tank on icecrown relamand im confused between warr and paladin
so what u advice me ?
and how to gear up instant 80 ?

[dike]

both classes are good.
for gearing - ez rep farm those fractions, buy some crafted **** from ah (dont forget about ulduar boe tank shield - must have!)

[Doorkicker5667]

For me, I'd choose pally. Pally Bubble is love, Pally Bubble is life. ROFL

[tinybadass]

Warriors are made for tanking and dps. No other class is better in these two things.

[Peustro]

I would recommend you a warrior. Warrior with protection talents has three charges - classic one, intercept, intervene, thus more mobility than a paladin. He also has a lot of button pressing to do, you will rarely run out of rage and your cooldowns will be reseting here and there. So if you're into very dynamic play warrior is the thing. As far as I am concered paladins are much more static and there isn't that much button smashing to do but on the other hand you get a class with a healing spec which you can use if you get tired of doing melee action.

[TheClam]

I've always been playing tank and stuff, roll warrior. Warrior is easily the best class to tank by far, or so I believe. Unlike palas and DKs, there's more skills to actively look for and use / potentially use as a warrior which makes the game less dull for me, but that's just an opinion, maybe you just want to spam the same 2 skills.
As for paladin, I think they're more fun as healers, but again, pretty spammy wammy, just press the same skill over and over and over. WOW can get pretty dull, so why not make it funner?

Play warrior.

[Thydus]

Warriors have good cooldown cycles so mitigation wise they can be great, Paladins are basic but they have the 'oh **** I forgot to use a cooldown' button that half this server needs cos brain farts

[Asphyxiation]

Play paladin if you're new to the game/expansion. Warriors are much harder to learn and master, especially if you have no knowledge about certain fight mechanics. Overall warriors are not as preferred as paladins when it comes to choosing a tank (unless warrior is needed for a certain raid comp or you are literally capable of playing anything at the highest level) - paladins have great raid support abilities as well as a tool to prevent a killing blow on them - http://wotlk.openwow.com/spell=31852. Paladins are also better than warriors when it comes to mitigation - damage on them isn't as spiky as it is on warriors due to http://wotlk.openwow.com/spell=53601 and http://wotlk.openwow.com/spell=48952 which means that the damage you take is a lot more consistent and it makes healers' lives easier.