Given my bad English, I use google translate, sorry for any grammatical errors.

First, I do not know if this is the place to ask this, I have been looking at where is the best place to ask, if the forum or a ticket, and I opted for this forum, because it seemed the most correct place, because I would like someone from the staff to answer me, If this is not the right place, forgive the inconvenience.

----

Hi, I have been looking and looking for everything related to the ninja loot topic, I have found several posts asking about ninja looting in various scenarios, I have also reviewed the rules of Warmane, but I have not found anything directly related to some doubts that I have.

The case is that I have encountered these situations several times, and I would like to know it clearly, because I see that in the game, many people do not understand how the statistics of their character work in WOTLK.


There are certain statistics that are for a specific role, such as the dodge or defense that is for the tank, or the mp5 that is for the healer, but the spirit? I do not understand why, an immense amount of healers believe that any item with the spirit statistic is theirs, and if you roll need, they start flaming you and say that they report you by ninja looter, and sometimes, not only the healers, the rest of the party that does not understand is on the side of the healer.
So I would like to know, if for example there is a ring / neck / cloak / etc that has statistics like 100int 50spirit 50haste, who can roll need?

If I'm a caster like Mage / Lock / SP / Boomkin, and I roll need to that item, and the 4 of the party, put a ticket for ninja loot, I can be banned by ninja loot?
(I have not put Elemental, because it is true that the elemental is the only dps caster that the spirit does not contribute anything to its dps.)

Because in my opinion, if the item were mp5 instead of spirit, yes, it is a healer item, but being spirit, I see it more than DPS.


And another similar scenario, but this is more concrete, that I also have doubts.

An item like https://wotlkdb.com/?item=37685 or https://wotlkdb.com/?item=37642, can a Warrior, Pala ret, or DK roll need? or would it be ninja loot? considering if there is a Rogue/Feral cat / Hunter / Enh in the party.
I know that for them agility is a main stat, just as for Warrior / Pala ret / DK it is strength, and if it is the other way around, for them strength does not contribute anything, but agility brings Crit to the Warrior / Pala ret / DK, taking into account that the great majority of the rings in this case, which provide strength are tank because they also give defense or dodge, the Warrior / Pala ret / DK have no other options.


Sorry if my doubts seem very strange, but seeing how many people are banned by ninja loot, when I find myself in those situations I am afraid to roll need. I guess that the GMs who review the cases of ninja loot, have more knowledge than these players who come from retail. But I would like to clarify my doubts, and thus be able to play more calmly.


Thanks for your work.